Aged Lead Store

2.5
Visit Website

Price Range

$1–$3/lead

Lead Types

Shared

Delivery

Same day

Contracts

No Contract

Guarantee

No

Free CRM

No

Editorial Review

Aged Lead Store is exactly what the name implies: a marketplace for leads that are 30 days to over a year old, sold at a fraction of the cost of fresh leads. At $0.50-3 per lead, the pricing is hard to beat, and for agents who have strong follow-up skills and persistence, aged leads can provide a surprisingly productive pipeline.

The value proposition is clear — these leads have been contacted before by other agents, but many prospects either were not ready at the time, got busy, or simply did not connect with the previous agent. A well-timed follow-up call weeks or months later can catch them at the right moment. The platform offers good filtering by age, geography, and lead type, and delivery is immediate since the leads already exist in their database.

The reality check: contact rates on aged leads are significantly lower than fresh leads. Expect to reach 10-20% of the people you call, and of those, only a fraction will still be interested. This is a volume game that rewards persistence and strong phone skills. Aged leads are excellent for new agents learning to sell, agents supplementing their fresh lead pipeline, or anyone looking to maximize their marketing budget. They are not a replacement for quality fresh leads.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Extremely low cost per lead ($0.50-3)
  • Good for new agents learning sales skills
  • Immediate delivery — no wait time
  • Wide variety of insurance verticals available
  • No contracts or minimum commitments

Cons

  • Very low contact rates compared to fresh leads
  • Leads have been previously contacted by other agents
  • Requires high volume and persistence to generate results
  • Not suitable as a primary lead source for most agents

Products & Pricing

ProductLead TypePrice Per Lead
Aged Final Expense LeadsAged$1.00
Aged Auto/Home LeadsAged$1.00
Aged Medicare LeadsAged$2.00

Agent Reviews

Write a Review

No reviews yet — be the first to review Aged Lead Store.

Compare Aged Lead Store with Similar Vendors

FEXmagnetEditor's Pick
4.9

Exclusive real-time Facebook and Instagram leads for final expense, IUL, and mortgage protection agents.

$25–$40/leadExclusiveNo ContractsReplacement Guarantee
View Profile →
3.8

Direct mail response leads for final expense and Medicare agents with high-intent prospects.

$20–$35/leadExclusiveNo Contracts
View Profile →
3.6

Exclusive digital leads for final expense and Medicare agents with no long-term contracts.

$20–$30/leadExclusiveNo Contracts
View Profile →